Insights · Physical Security

Walking through a facility at night changes the conclusions

Plans describe the layout and shift schedules describe the operation. The differences between the two tend to centre on access points and closing procedures.

Every facility has its moment of truth. It falls roughly between midnight and three in the morning, when almost everyone has gone home and the site is down to the bare minimum: a skeleton shift, night lighting and the usual procedures. It is advisable not to consider any physical security audit complete without having been there at that hour. The point is to see the facility working, which is very different from seeing it pose.

The daytime visit is essential, but it has something of a school play about it. Everyone is there, the access points are used the way the procedure says, and there is always someone beside you explaining each thing. At midday, the plans and reality look very much alike. The problem is that a good share of incidents do not happen at midday. Anyone coming to steal, to sneak in or simply to look around picks precisely the hours when the system is running on a skeleton crew, and those are the hours the security plan covers in a few lines.

On the last night walk I did, the security guard showed me his site, which was not exactly the one in the drawings. The emergency door at the back was wedged open with a wooden block, and my first note was not a breach, it was to ask why. It turned out that the bell at the loading bay does not ring in his guardhouse, so if he shut the door completely, the early-morning delivery driver was left outside banging on the metal. That wedged door was not indiscipline, it was a bell in the wrong place. A few metres further on, the temporary access that a contractor opened months ago was still open, with the works long finished and nobody watching it. The lighting, uniform on paper, left three shadows on the ground, coincidentally in the three places where I most wanted to look. And the key to the plant room was where these keys always are: where everyone knows.

Then there is the closing routine, which takes up a single line in the procedure and in reality is shared between three people and two shifts. Who locks what, in what order, what is checked, and what is assumed to be locked simply because it always has been. The night shift carries all of this from memory, and it costs them nothing to explain it if you ask while walking beside them, rather than requesting it in writing. That night, the guard said something I have noted down for every project since: "This place is a different place at night." Security only means something in a specific situation, and the night situation is not the day one with less light. It is a different situation, with different assets in practice, different procedures and different threats, and it deserves its own conclusions.

And what changes in the conclusions? Almost always, the order of the recommendations. Seen at night, the showy investment loses its place to humbler things: a light where the shadow is, a bell that rings where there is someone to hear it, a locking-up routine with names on it, and a fresh look at the accesses that were once temporary. The treatment each finding deserves changes too. The workaround that points at a design flaw is corrected by touching the design, and the genuine breach is corrected by talking to people. Mixing them up in the report, and turning the person who wedged the door into the headline, is in many cases reckless, and a way of chasing the spotlight.

If you run a facility, let me suggest something very simple. The next time you review it, stay until everyone has left, or come back once they are gone, and walk the rounds with the night shift, letting them talk: they have spent years waiting for someone to ask. Your facility will tell you things the security plan does not know.

If this resonates with something you are seeing in your organisation, let's talk.

Let's talk