Violence in public-facing roles: what happens before the incident
Physical or verbal assaults in the retail sector are almost never sudden for those working in customer-facing roles. We discuss how to pick up on these early warning signs, what can and cannot be expected of a shop team, and how to provide support afterwards.
Carmen has been a shop manager at a fashion boutique in a shopping centre for eleven years. One Tuesday afternoon, a man walked in with a crumpled receipt in his hand, and she knew, before he even reached the till, that something was amiss. If you ask her how she knew, she just shrugs. His strides were longer than usual, his jaw was clenched, the way he walked through the crowd. Eleven years of working with the public have turned thousands of interactions into a radar that works all by itself.
That afternoon, Carmen did three very simple things. Using the code phrase they had agreed on, she asked her newest colleague to fetch a box from the stockroom, which is her way of saying step out and raise the alarm. She positioned herself on the side of the counter that leaves an exit open. And she served the man with a mixture of calm and firmness that cannot be improvised, while the shopping centre security guard, alerted by a rehearsed gesture, made himself visible for a moment in front of the shop window. The return ended with a size exchange and an "I'm sorry, I've had a horrible day". Nothing happened.
And since nothing happened, it does not exist. There is no report, no record, no data. The company's system will only learn anything on the day a similar incident ends in insults or something worse, and then the report will say it was sudden. It was not sudden: Carmen saw it coming from the doorway. The thing is, no one has given her a place to record what she sees, nor any reason to believe that recording it will change anything. For me, that is the first step in a violence prevention programme, and it is also one of the cheapest: a simple channel where staff can note what happened, when it happened and who was there, even when the scare remains just a scare. Especially when it remains just a scare, because that is precisely where the information lives that can still be acted on in time.
From there, we need to be fair and realistic about what we ask of shop staff, because it is all too easy to be unfair here. We can ask them to observe and report incidents promptly, and train them properly to do so: assertive communication, reading non-verbal cues, how to keep a safe distance, how to withdraw in time, and how to ask for help without escalating the situation. We can provide them with a panic button, a walkie-talkie or an alert app, provided there is a living protocol in place rather than just a notice in the back room. What we cannot ask them to do is physically restrain anyone, win an argument with a customer who will not take no for an answer, or put themselves at physical or emotional risk waiting for help that nobody has defined. And there is something that is constantly expected of them without being said out loud: that they absorb the emotional cost as if it were included in their pay packet.
At a talk for the AECOC congress I asked the question point-blank: is violence part of the job? I do not think so. And if your organisation's answer is also no, the division of roles must be set out in writing and in detail. The team observes, alerts and protects itself. Restraint belongs to a professional, whether that is a security guard or the police.
Then there is the aftermath, which is where a programme's true colours show. When a team member goes through an incident like this, supporting them does not mean telling them what to do. It means going with them to report it, covering their shifts during the trial if there is one, giving them time to recover, offering them a spell in another shop if they need it, and providing genuine psychological support. And it means communicating clearly to the rest of the team how it was handled, because everyone is watching how things unfold. A team that feels it makes no difference learns to keep quiet, and that silence ultimately takes its toll in absences, in turnover and in that lack of enthusiasm we later call a lack of commitment, as if it had arisen of its own accord.
How many Cármenes do you have in your shops? How many things did they notice this week that are not written down anywhere? Looking after the teams who face the public means looking after your customers; I wrote about it in Cuadernos de Seguridad and every project confirms it. Next month's incident is already giving notice today, in one of your shops, in some other form. It is worth having a place where those signals land, and a team that knows that raising the alarm actually makes a difference.
If this resonates with something you are seeing in your organisation, let's talk.
Let's talk